Imagine you have a needy relative who’s always hitting you up for money. The person’s a nudge, irresponsible, undependable and ungrateful.
Should you keep loaning that person your money?
That scenario has been a hot topic on the Internet for a month. It’s the first “moral dilemma” posed on “The Jewish Ethics Project,” a new Facebook group established by Rabbi Joseph Telushkin.
Founded as a follow-up to Rabbi Telushkin’s latest book, “A Code of Jewish Ethics, Volume 2: Love Your Neighbor as Yourself” (Bell Tower, 2009), the Facebook group (www.jewishethicsproject.netbounce.com) is the first one that offers such interactive moral suasion from a Jewish perspective, the rabbi says.
But it’s open to anyone, and many of the first 500-plus members are not Jewish.
“I wanted to put a renewed emphasis on Jewish ethical teachings,” says Rabbi Telushkin, a prolific author and lecturer. “I want to affect and elevate people’s behavior. You reach people [on Facebook] whom you might otherwise not reach.”
Each week he introduces a particular ethical topic, augmented by a dilemma to which the group’s members respond.
The dilemmas, like the shnorrer relative, are more about intrapersonal issues than current headline topics. “Family resonates,” Rabbi Telushkin.
Georgianna Johnson, a group member from Massachusetts, says she joined after she read “A Code of Jewish Ethics” and did some online research about the rabbi. “The book was addressing some issues I was discussing.” Johnson, who is Catholic, is a student of Scripture. The Facebook group, she says, lets her learn more about “Scripture the way it is taught” in the original Jewish tradition.
“It’s really a nice group,” Johnson says. “It’s really worthwhile to participate.
“I’ve posted a couple of times,” taking part in discussions about one of the rabbi’s moral dilemmas, she says,
Responses to the first dilemma ranged, Rabbi Telushkin says. Stop giving money to a miscreant, some people suggested. Don’t stop, said others.
The rabbi’s own answer?
Support the New York Jewish Week
Our nonprofit newsroom depends on readers like you. Make a donation now to support independent Jewish journalism in New York.
None, so far. “The message is sometimes there isn’t necessarily a definitive answer to every question.” Sometimes, the rabbi says, he’s more interested in provoking thoughtful discussion than in providing a definitive answer. “This one, I may leave open.”
The New York Jewish Week brings you the stories behind the headlines, keeping you connected to Jewish life in New York. Help sustain the reporting you trust by donating today.
