A recent Opinion piece, “Exclude Me At Your Own Peril” (Oct. 26) by a fellow Columbia University student, depicted the ostensible fragmentation and dissolution of the pro-Israel movement, especially a Columbia. It described the necessity to acknowledge the conflict at home – referring to the growing division in the Jewish community concerning Israel and Israeli policy – before addressing the conflict abroad.
I write today to tell a very different story.
On November 18, the Columbia Students for Justice in Palestine staged a “mock Israeli checkpoint” on Low Plaza. Less than 48 hours before, Columbia/Barnard Hillel was notified of the demonstration and the pro-Israel groups on campus, along with their allies, mobilized to assemble a coordinated response.
LionPAC, the largest pro-Israel group on campus, of which I am vice president, helped marshal not only our own community at Columbia, but also our friends and colleagues from around New York City.
What I witnessed that Thursday, as the Students for Justice in Palestine were putting on their show, was an incredible turnout of support for the Jewish and pro-Israel communities.
What we saw while positioned directly opposite the C-SJP, was a radical and misleading demonstration of Israeli checkpoints in the West Bank.
The message of the C-SJP was not about peace, security, or even reality; in fact it represented a gross violation of everything Columbia stands for.
Although freedom of speech is held in the utmost regard at Columbia, as epitomized by the controversial 2007 visit by Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, these students’ free speech only espoused hatred and negativity.
The organizers of the C-SJP checkpoint had students line up, be led to the middle of the plaza, then forced onto their knees, blindfolded, and had their hands tied behind their backs.
They did this to every student who participated. It was a gross distortion of the daily reality at checkpoints in the West Bank.
In response, the pro-Israel students of Columbia and many others turned out in droves to form a coalition of various opinions and ideologies.
LionPAC, Just Peace, the Israel Cultural Society, and Garin Lavi, all rallied under Hillel’s direction to present a unified front against this anti-Israel effort. We were joined by organizations such a StandWithUs, Hasbara, the David Project, Hagshama and the Zionist Organization of America.
Support the New York Jewish Week
Our nonprofit newsroom depends on readers like you. Make a donation now to support independent Jewish journalism in New York.
Our theme was of discussion and debate grounded in factual information about checkpoints. Our motto was "it’s complicated."
We stated clearly that checkpoints can be very frustrating, upsetting and often make life difficult for Palestinians, but they exist for a reason.
We provided balanced information and stories so that our fellow students at Columbia could make informed and educated decisions, something the C-SJP systematically rejected. In a press release the following day they wrote “C-SJP maintains a firm stance that this is not a ‘conflict’ that requires ‘dialogue.’”
This is not an isolated incident. The campus protests against Israel have grown over the last decade. Jewish and non-Jewish students who support Israel are constantly under fire and pressure from anti-Israel groups and anti-Israel professors.
This month alone saw an effort to boycott Sabra Hummus at Princeton University, mock checkpoints at Columbia and at Brooklyn College, and the hosting of Norman Finkelstein at Rutgers in an effort to promote a United States-led flotilla to Gaza.
At a time when Israel is being attacked abroad and by academics and students at home, the pro-Israel community cannot afford to squabble and engage in petty arguments.
Whether you agree or disagree on settlements, whether you lean left or right politically, whether you identify with J Street, AIPAC or ZOA, is of no consequence when Israel’s very right to exist is being questioned. Generating an artificial conflict at home only serves to distract our community and belittle the true conflict that exists abroad.
Whenever I speak about Columbia and the challenges we face, I say with conviction that I truly believe my campus is predominantly pro-Israel.
This is exemplified by the ability of every single Israel-related group to put internal issues aside in order to stand as one group together in support of Israel against a demonizing anti-Israel group.
It is demonstrated by the hundreds of supporters who came to help in our effort that Thursday, Jew and non-Jew alike, holding signs and giving out fact sheets and information. And it is represented by the positive feedback we received and the dialogue that occurred as a result of that coordinated effort.
What we learned from that day is that the pro-Israel community at every university in the country must put differences aside in order to join hands in defending Israel. Not doing so only widens the divide in our own community, and gives Israel’s detractors greater opportunity in their persistent and unrelenting campaign to delegitimize its creation and its right to exist as a Jewish democratic state.
Eric J. Schorr is vice president of LionPAC, a pro-Israel advocacy group at Columbia University, and a StandWithUs Emerson Fellow. He is also a student at The Jewish Theological Seminary.
Support the New York Jewish Week
Our nonprofit newsroom depends on readers like you. Make a donation now to support independent Jewish journalism in New York.
The New York Jewish Week brings you the stories behind the headlines, keeping you connected to Jewish life in New York. Help sustain the reporting you trust by donating today.
