At its last Cleveland convention, the GOP nominated a friend of refugees — and Jews
Menu JTA Search
Election 2016

At its last Cleveland convention, the GOP nominated a friend of refugees — and Jews

Republican candidate Alf Landon arriving on a train in Pasadena during the 1936 presidential campaign. (Austrian Archives/Imagno/Getty Images)

Republican candidate Alf Landon arriving on a train in Pasadena during the 1936 presidential campaign. (Austrian Archives/Imagno/Getty Images)

Monday night, a series of speakers at the Republican National Convention in Cleveland told voters to elect Donald Trump, who has repeatedly called for a ban on Muslim immigration to the United States. One of the speakers, Sabine Durden, said “crooked Hillary always talks about what she will do for illegal aliens and for refugees. Well, Donald Trump talks about what he will do for Americans.”

But the last time the Republicans met in Cleveland, their nominee wanted to let refugees become Americans. Alf Landon, nominated at the 1936 Republican National Convention, was an outspoken critic of Nazi persecution of Jews. Later, he advocated bringing Jewish refugees to America, and supported the establishment of a Jewish state.

Landon was the governor of Kansas, a state with relatively few Jews. But in 1933, according to a JTA dispatch, Landon denounced “the inhuman treatment now accorded the Jews in Germany.” That statement, according to Rafael Medoff, director of The David S. Wyman Institute for Holocaust Studies, was more than President Franklin D. Roosevelt ever said publicly about Nazi anti-Semitism before 1938.

“He didn’t have any particular connection to the Jewish community in Kansas, he didn’t have any major Jewish donors of whom I’m aware,” said Medoff. “He didn’t have any ostensible reason for doing it other than that the plight of the Jews appealed to him on a straightforward humanitarian basis.”

Kansas Governor Alf Landon lost to Franklin Roosevelt in the 1936 election. (Wikimedia Commons)

Kansas Governor Alf Landon lost to Franklin Roosevelt in the 1936 election. (Wikimedia Commons)

The statement didn’t help Landon in 1936. Jews were considered such a solid Democratic constituency that year, says Medoff, that Landon didn’t even campaign for their votes. A component of the juggernaut New Deal coalition, Jews voted overwhelmingly for Roosevelt in 1936, giving him 85 percent of their votes. The president would earn 90 percent of Jewish votes in 1940 and again in 1944. Jewish leaders remained loyal to Roosevelt and didn’t build relationships with Landon.

(Republican efforts to draw Jewish voters have intensified during the past several elections, to little avail. Seventy percent of Jews voted for President Barack Obama in 2012. Conservative Washington Post columnist Jennifer Rubin predicted last week that presumptive Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton could get 90 percent of the Jewish vote in 2016 — tying Roosevelt’s number.)

But unpopularity didn’t stop Landon from advocating for the Nazis’ Jewish victims. Days after Kristallnacht, in November 1938, Landon called on Americans in a radio address to protest on behalf of European Jews.

In 1939, according to Medoff, he was one of few Republicans to support the Wagner-Rogers bill, which would have allowed 20,000 Jewish refugee children into the United States (though, JTA reported, Landon “expressed the wish that the age limit of 14 was lower and warned of a later demand that parents of the children be given consideration”). The bill died in committee. A few years later, Medoff writes that Landon praised a Revisionist Zionist position paper calling for mass Jewish emigration to Palestine ahead of the creation of a Jewish state.

The head of the American Revisionist Zionists? Benzion Netanyahu, father of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. So along with being one of the only politicians to welcome refugees, Landon was among the first of many Republicans to like a Netanyahu.