Search JTA's historical archive dating back to 1923

“manchester Guardian” Outlines Questions to Be Investigated by Proposed Palestine Commission Suggest

December 23, 1929
See Original Daily Bulletin From This Date
Advertisement

If You Are Pleased with the “Jewish Daily Bulletin” Tel Your Friends to Subscribe

The request for an authoritative commission to consider the whole working of the Palestine Mandate made in a joint letter to the London “Times” by Lord Balfour, David Lloyd George and General Jan Smuts, will be difficult to refuse, declares the “Manchester Guardian” today, for, says the “Guardian,” “it is abundantly clear that in 1917 we did not fully appreciate the complexity of the problem.”

Pointing out that the most serious difficulty is the question of colonizing an already occupied country, the “Guardian” says that the “constant Arab suspicion in connection with land purchase is exercising a most disquieting influence. Such suspicions may be unavoidable but perhaps something might be done to lessen them if the whole matter was brought under a more direct state control.

“Then there is the question of Jewish immigration and the rate at which Palestine can absorb it. In recent tendency for the number of emigrants to approach, and even on occasion to exceed the number of new arrivals. This symptom of ill health can only be cured by a thoroughly expert diagnosis which will take into account the flow of capital, the type of settler and the prevailing market conditions.

“The Palestine government has done much to probe this problem but more remains to be done. Many feel that in its broad lines that is a matter for the Mandatory power itself rather than for its representatives. These are some of the questions which would form a legitimate field for the contemplated inquiry. If it is to be effective it should be limited to economic and social questions for under the peculiar Palestine conditions there can be little doubt that the form of government will have to remain in its essence a benevolent despotism for a considerable period.”

The London “Daily Mail”, picking out a sentence from the joint letter, “we view with deep anxiety the pres- (Continued on Page 7)

If You Are Pleased with the “Jewish Daily Bulletin” Tel Your Friends to Subscribe

Recommended from JTA

Advertisement