So you're sitting there in the darkened theater, excited to see "Knocked Up," which has been hailed by pretty much everyone as one of the most hilarious, edgy, envelope-pushing comedies of the year. And you're enjoying it quite a bit when all of a sudden, there it is like a thunderbolt an overt conversation
about Jewish identity in a completely secular context.
Those of you who are concerned that this might constitute a spoiler, turn off for the next paragraph. Or just watch the clip on YouTube.
So what I've learned from watching this film is that when a group of Jewish guys goes to a bar to drink and pick up women, it's bound to become a discussion of how Jews are depicted on film. For those of you who can't view YouTube video on your computers, get a new computer. But for your benefit, here's a summary, with expletives deleted.
Ben (Seth Rogen) is sitting around a bar with his friends, played by Jason Segel, Jay Baruchel and Jonah Hill (and named Jason, Jay and Jonah, respectively), talking about how awesome the movie "Munich" was. In other movies, he notes animatedly, Jews are always getting killed, but in "Munich," Eric Bana plays a Mossad agent who kicks major ass. Ben says that if any of them get lucky that night it's because of Eric Bana. Then they start making fun of the only non-Jew in the bunch, who says "I'm glad I'm not Jewish." Ben counters, "So are we," adding later, "You weren't chosen for a reason."
Throughout the film there are additional such shout-outs to being Jewish, including one random, facial hair-provoked reference to Matisyahu. But on the whole, such references are cultural, and the main obstacle to the union between the two characters is not religion but lifestyle he's a slacker, she's a career girl. One might be tempted to read several things into the premise for the movie: that schlubby guys who are really good-hearted people deserve tall, gorgeous blondes, or that Jewish stoner guys can attain a previously unattainable ideal. Or we could use the onscreen moments of Jewish identity discussion to provoke a larger discussion.
Of course, there's yet another way to derive something from "Knocked Up": Just sit back and enjoy one of the funniest films of the year.