News Analysis: Foreign Workers in Israel a Potential Social Time Bomb
Menu JTA Search

News Analysis: Foreign Workers in Israel a Potential Social Time Bomb

Download PDF for this date

There is a social time bomb ticking away in Israel, and Israeli authorities have been doing little to defuse it.

With each closure Israel imposed on the West Bank and Gaza Strip in the wake of repeated onslaughts of Arab terror, thousands of Palestinian workers were prevented from working in Israel, primarily at low-paying agricultural and construction jobs.

To make up for the shortfall in unskilled workers, the Jewish state began authorizing the import of workers from farther afield — Thailand, Romania, Turkey, the Philippines.

The number of such workers now stands at about 250,000 — of whom some 150,000 are working illegally, said government officials.

Many of the illegal workers originally came to Israel as tourists and decided to stay. Others came to Israel under valid work permits and remained beyond the one-year legal time limit.

Their wages, far below the wages of the average Israeli worker, are nonetheless higher than what they can expect at home.

So they remain in Israel, often living in cramped, substandard housing.

They are not a burden to social services, so long as they have valid visas, which are issued by the Interior Ministry only after the applicant has received a work permit from the Ministry of Labor.

But once the permits expire, they have no one to pay their health bills.

If they have families, they are not entitled to any of the social benefits given to Israelis, including education.

Nor do the illegal workers have much hope for any improvement of their lot. They can become Israeli citizens only if they marry an Israeli. If they have children while in Israel, their offspring also remain illegal aliens.

President Ezer Weizman recently warned of the dangers of hosting a large foreign community without the proper facilities.

Many of the construction workers, for example, live in improvised housing provided by their employers. There are often as many as eight people to a room, where they live in slumlike conditions.

In another sign of growing alarm from government officials, the Interior Ministry has warned that if the illegal workers remain deprived of medical attention they may become a source of serious diseases that could spread throughout the country.

Although police officials say the rate of crime among illegal workers is no higher than in Israeli society at large, some are concerned that poverty and substandard living conditions will in time ratchet up the crime rate among them.

In an effort to clamp down on illegal workers, inspection teams from the Ministry of Labor go on daily raids at construction sites to check foreign workers’ papers.

But the inspection team numbers only 70 officials — hardly a sufficient force to cope with a quarter million foreign workers.

The scope of the problem has recently come under the scrutiny of the Interior Ministry.

Some 40,000 illegal workers come from the former Communist bloc, according to ministry figures.

Another 45,000 come from Asia and Africa, 15,000 from Latin America and 10,000 from Arab countries such as Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt and Morocco.

Most of the construction workers are Romanians and Turks; most of the farm workers Thais; Filipinos are very popular as nannies or as companions for the elderly; and most of the African workers are doing cleaning jobs.

With an unemployment rate of 6 percent, the Israeli economy can well tolerate the presence of legally imported foreign workers.

As a result of the influx of the foreign workers, the look and feel of many Israeli neighborhoods are changing.

An international gallery of people, mostly from Ghana and Nigeria, can be seen in the area around the former Central Bus Station in southern Tel Aviv.

A large Tel Aviv coffee house, Turkish Coffee, plays host to scores of Turks who come after working hours to play backgammon and cards or to watch Turkish television and drink tea.

At Herzliya Pituah, the luxury quarter of Herzliya that is home to diplomats and Israel’s high society, one can see Filipino nannies taking children out for strolls or taking the boss’ car for a shopping errand.

“The Israelis like us, they trust us. Why should they replace us?” said Simo Delfin, 46, of the Philippines.

Delfin, who came to Israel eight years ago after he divorced his wife, left six children behind in Manila.

He cleans homes and offices in Herzliya and Tel Aviv, makes at least $2,000 a month and sends $800 home to his children.

But he dares not leave to visit them, for fear that the Israeli authorities will not allow him back in. Originally allowed into Israel on a tourist visa, he is now illegally employed in the Jewish state.

But while he questions why Israel wants to deport him, the Interior Ministry recently said that it was seeking to remove 100,000 foreign workers.

The deportations, which can be contested in court by workers or their employers, may possibly reflect a broader political motive.

The recently installed government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has partially lifted the closure on the West Bank and Gaza in order to ease the prolonged financial hardship it has caused to Palestinian workers.

The closure had been imposed after the first of four Hamas terror attacks on Israel in late February and early March.

As part of the relaxed closure, an additional 10,000 Palestinian workers were issued work permits this week, bringing the total number of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip allowed to work in Israel to 35,000.

Ten years ago, some 160,000 Palestinians held jobs in Israel.

Closures are regularly imposed by Israel in response to terror, but they have brought repeated criticisms from the international community, which points to a markedly decaying Palestinian economy.

And some Israeli officials, while not attacking the policy of temporary closures, have recently argued against those seeking to establish a permanent separation between the Israeli and Palestinian populations as a way of coping with terror attacks.

The separation plan, these officials say, would only serve to give Palestinians an additional argument for the formation of an independent Palestinian state that would have borders drawn roughly along the same lines that are de facto being established by the repeated closures.

Clearly, if the closures are ever fully lifted, many of the foreign workers in Israel would have to be displaced to make room for their Palestinian counterparts.

Moreover, authorities cannot tolerate a situation of “soft borders” where illegal workers insinuate themselves into the fabric of Israeli society. Given these concerns, the issue of foreign workers — both legal and illegal — may well start moving to a position of greater priority on the agenda of the Netanyahu government.

Founding Funders

The digitization of the JTA Archive would not have been possible without the generous support of the following donors:
  • The Gottesman Fund
  • Righteous Persons Foundation
  • Charles H. Revson Foundation
  • Elisa Spungen Bildner and Robert Bildner, in honor of Norma Spungen
  • George S. Blumenthal
  • Grace and Scott Offen Charitable Fund