Waiting for 61 Latest episode · Nov. 9 Unpacking Trump on 60 Minutes and Tension in the Change Bloc Listen · 19 min

Israel discussion exposes gaps between Lander and Avila Chevalier

One congressional candidate was asked about an Oct. 8, 2023 pro-Palestinian protest that she attended. Her fellow Democrat called it “abominable” at the time.

Advertisement
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Two Democratic congressional nominees, Brad Lander and Darializa Avila Chevalier, spoke on a panel about Israel and the Democratic Party that exposed some of the gaps between the two progressives on Sunday.

Both candidates, who are expected to win office in November, were endorsed by New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and appeared in a campaign ad together alongside fellow Mamdani endorsee Claire Valdez. They spoke during an all-day event hosted by left-wing magazine Jewish Currents. 

The magazine’s editor-at-large Peter Beinart asked the candidates where Democrats should draw the line on what is considered legitimate Palestinian resistance. He pointed to the pro-Palestinian protest held in New York City on Oct. 8, 2023, which Avila Chevalier attended and Lander called “abominable” at the time.

“I think international law has already drawn that line,” Avila Chevalier said, arguing that U.S. protests should target Israel, which receives U.S. support, rather than Hamas.

“We could be the biggest anti-Hamas protesters, but a protest against Hamas in the U.S. isn’t going to do anything because we don’t fund it,” said Avila Chevalier, who helped lead Columbia University’s pro-Palestinian encampment in 2024. “We don’t have any structural power over it, there is nothing tying us to that institution other than condemning it endlessly.”

After the event, Lander, who is Jewish, did not confirm to the Jewish Telegraphic Agency whether he had spoken about that Oct. 8 protest with Avila Chevalier.

“We have talked about these issues broadly in private, and I don’t want to characterize those conversations,” Lander told JTA. “And obviously I’ve made my feelings known in public, and I stand by them. I mean, on that day, I was in mourning.”

Lander, who had been a dues-paying member of the Democratic Socialists of America, has since said that he stopped paying dues over the New York City DSA chapter’s participation in that protest.

“Today’s DSA rally — which effectively celebrated Hamas’ murder & kidnapping of hundreds of Israeli civilians, including children & grandparents — was abominable,” he wrote at the time. “There is no place for glorifying terror, left, center, or right.”

An attendee named Mark, 29, who declined to share his last name to avoid potential workplace complications, said he felt that Avila Chevalier “didn’t really acknowledge the criticism about perhaps disregarding loss of life; despite the power imbalance, it is lost life.”

For Lander, meanwhile, Mark said it was “politically expedient” for him to not directly address Avila Chevalier’s presence at the 2023 protest. “This is a super lefty crowd that probably would eat him alive if he went against her right now,” he said.

During the panel, Avila Chevalier repeated her call for an arms embargo against Israel while Lander stopped short of doing so, consistent with his statements in the past that Israel should be able to buy defensive weapons with its own funds. Both said Congress must pass the Block the Bombs Act and vote to suspend the sale of offensive U.S. military weapons to Israel. Lander was the only speaker on stage who advocated for a two-state solution in the region.

Georgia state Rep. Ruwa Romman, the first Palestinian American elected to public office in her state, was asked on the same panel about Jon Ossoff, the Jewish Democratic senator running for reelection in her state. Addressing the senator’s stance on Palestinian issues, she said she was pleased that both Georgia senators have been consistently voting in favor of Bernie Sanders’ resolution to block arms sales to Israel, but added that “in terms of leading, in terms of rhetoric, there’s still a lot of work to be done.”

“We’ll get everyone to where we need them to be eventually,” she said.

Hasan Piker calls out pro-Palestinian protesters

Also at the Jewish Currents event, Hasan Piker, the popular streamer who has campaigned for a number of democratic socialist candidates, called the protesters who jeered Mamdani at an Oct. 7 vigil last week “opportunists,” who “tarnished” the anti-Zionist movement’s message.

Speaking on a panel titled “Can the Left Wield Power?”, he said that the protesters had “valid concerns,” including demands like firing police commissioner Jessica Tisch and disbanding the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, a heavily armed unit that often responds to protests.

But he criticized the DSA — the left-wing political organization that Mamdani has called his “political home” — for not playing a bigger role in last week’s protest, which started at City Hall and later overran an Israeli peace vigil. DSA did not sponsor the protest, though some campus chapters of its student section, the Young DSA, participated.

“The DSA not being at the forefront of the anti-Zionist mobilization in New York City is what allowed that mobilization to be tarnished by opportunists, sectarians and those who actually were calling him a genocidaire — which I obviously find to be ridiculous,” Piker said, referring to protesters’ chants of “Mayor Mamdani you can’t hide, we charge you with genocide.”

Piker, who has drawn heat for his anti-Israel views, did not comment on the Hamas iconography displayed by numerous protesters, nor the decision to crash an Oct. 7 vigil that memorialized the 1,200 people killed in the Hamas-led attacks on that date in 2023, and the 74,000 Palestinians who have been killed since then, according to Gaza health ministry figures, which do not distinguish civilians from combatants.

Separately, Mahmoud Khalil, the Columbia University pro-Palestinian protest leader who was detained by ICE last year, reportedly criticized those protesters’ “purity politics” during an event in Washington, D.C. 

“You don’t have to agree with someone 100 percent — 85 percent is good,” he said, provided that the end goal is “liberating Palestine and ending the unconditional support of the United States.”

‘The bund is back in town’

The Jewish Labor Bund — the early 20th-century socialist movement that fought against Bolshevism, Nazism and Zionism — came up at numerous points on Sunday. One attendee doled out fliers with a website URL and the message, “Tell your bubbe the bund is back in town.” It was also a subject of a conversation that featured Molly Crabapple, whose 2026 book “Here Where We Live is Our Country” focuses on the Bund.

Arlene Geiger, an Upper West Sider and longtime activist, told JTA that she related to those conversations.

“My connection to Judaism is not to Israel, it never has been. It’s more to Eastern Europe and the Bund, so that spoke to me,” Geiger said.

Mark, who is from New Jersey, said he doesn’t come from a “staunchly pro-Zionist” family, but that he has a new interest in leftist Jewish spaces since realizing that he could no longer comfortably distance himself from the issue of Israel, which he believes is committing a genocide.

“It’s just an education for me to be immersed in this kind of space,” he said.

This story was updated to focus on the gaps between progressive New York congressional candidates Brad Lander and Darializa Avila Chevalier. An earlier version focused Hasan Piker and his reaction to pro-Palestinian protesters at a Oct. 7 vigil in New York City.

Count yourself in. Jewish New York has always shown up for itself. Join your neighbors with a year-end gift by Dec. 31. We can’t do it without you.

Choose an amount to donate
Advertisement