Waiting for 61 New episode · Nov. 8 Gadi Eisenkot Was Asked to Form a Government. What Happens Now? Listen · 24 min

Sections

EST 1917
Advertisement

Behind the Headlines; Will Bush Leadership in Gulf Crisis Bring Dividends for Gop at the Polls?

March 11, 1991
See Original Daily Bulletin From This Date

President Bush’s success in destroying Iraq’s offensive military capabilities and thereby neutralizing Israel’s most dangerous enemy has brought him unprecedented popularity within the American Jewish community.

Jewish Republicans hope this, coupled with the speed with which Bush came to Israel’s aid when it was under attack from Iraqi missiles, will translate into increased Jewish votes for the president when he seeks re-election next year.

But Jewish Democrats maintain the war will be a distant memory by the time the 1992 elections roll around and that domestic issues will keep the Jewish vote where it has traditionally been, overwhelmingly in the Democratic column.

Both Democrats and Republicans agree that what happens in the current effort to bring about a solution to the Arab-Israeli conflict and the Palestinian issue could play an important role in deciding how Jews vote in November 1992.

“The president has certainly earned the respect and admiration of most Jews,” said Richard Fox of Philadelphia, chairman of the National Jewish Coalition, which promotes Republican candidates among Jewish voters.

This should bring about more Jewish votes for Bush next year, “all other things being equal,” Fox said. He explained that no one can predict what will happen as the Bush administration begins postwar efforts to bring about peace in the Middle East.

“My belief is that the president will be sensitive to Israeli concerns, as he has been so far,” Fox said.

Jacob Stein, a longtime Jewish Republican activist, said he found it hard to understand why the Jewish community did not respond more affirmatively than it did to Bush in 1988.

BUSH ‘DESERVES’ JEWISH VOTE

But Bush’s determination during the Persian Gulf crisis should remove “any doubts” about his leadership ability, Stein said. He said Bush has also demonstrated his determination to help Israel make peace.

“I would certainly hope in the 1992 election there is a realization in the Jewish community that President Bush deserves their vote,” he said.

Morton Mandel of Cleveland, chairman of the National Jewish Democratic Council, a group founded last year to promote the Democratic Party among Jewish voters, also had words of praise for Bush’s leadership in the Gulf crisis.

“I think the president deserves a lot of praise,” he said. But “when it comes to elect the next president, there is a lot more to consider.”

He said the Jewish community is interested in many issues, including prayer in the public schools, social and economic issues, and the state of relations between the United States and Israel.

“This is where the ‘tachlis’ is going to be in terms of 1992,” Mandel said, using the Hebrew-Yiddish word for “substance.” He believes that because of the Republican stance on these issues, most Jews will vote with the Democrats.

Stuart Eizenstat, a Washington lawyer who was President Jimmy Carter’s assistant for domestic affairs, said there is “no question that there has been an enormous surge of support in the Jewish community” for Bush. But this is “unlikely to translate into any long-term trend in Jewish voting behavior,” he said.

Eizenstat argued that “Jewish Democratic support is so profoundly rooted” that even in the 1984 landslide victory of President Ronald Reagan, who was considered one of the most pro-Israel presidents, only 25 to 30 percent of the Jewish vote went to him.

AN UNFRIENDLY ADMINISTRATION?

But Matthew Brooks, executive director of the National Jewish Coalition, believes that it is the domestic agenda that will help move Jews into the Republican column.

People want to move away from the traditional Democratic liberal approach to solve social issues through government intervention, he said.

He said Jews should find the Republican idea of empowerment, allowing people to help themselves, more in line with traditional Jewish values.

“I think we really have a unique opportunity to take advantage of a window that now exists and do much better in the upcoming presidential election,” Brooks said.

“People now realize when push comes to shove, George Bush stood behind Israel and helped defend it,” Brooks said.

Recalling the success of Patriot missiles in shooting down Iraqi Scuds aimed at Israel, Brooks said it is in “many ways irreconcilable” for Democrats to support a militarily strong Israel while “scaling back the U.S. military.”

But Steve Gutow, executive director of the National Jewish Democratic Council, said he was “sure that the great majority of Jewish voters will adhere to the Democratic Party.” He said once the euphoria over the war ends, most Jews will continue to support the Democrats because of issues like civil liberties and civil rights.

He also believes that Jews will not vote for Bush because of his frequent clashes with Israel, such as the one in which U.S. loan guarantees for $400 million to provide housing for Soviet Jews was held up for close to a year.

The Bush administration “has been one of the least friendly administrations to Israel,” he said, “and most Jewish Americans know it.”

Eizenstat observed that the election will be held 18 months after the war’s end. While the war will not be forgotten, the peace process will be closer to the minds of American Jews, he said.

SPECTER OF ANTI-WAR VOTE

Eizenstat predicts periods of tensions between Israel and the United States, since he believes the administration will focus more on the Palestinian issue than on bringing the Arabs states to the negotiating table with Israel.

One issue the Republicans are expected to use against Democrats is that most Democrats in Congress voted against authorizing Bush to use force against Saddam Hussein. Jews in the House and Senate were split on the issue, but the majority voted against authorizing force.

The Democrats were not against using force, Mandel argued. They only wanted to give the sanctions against Iraq “more time,” he explained.

All of this speculation may be premature. Not only is it too early to know what issues will be in the forefront in the fall of 1992, but the outcome will also depend on who the Democratic Party picks as its nominee. Right now, that is the biggest unknown of all, as few have stepped forward to compete for the Democratic ticket.

A Season of Big Decisions. From the Knesset campaign to American midterms, Jewish communities are weighing what comes next. Help JTA keep delivering the deeper context.

Choose an amount to donate

Recommended from JTA

Advertisement