Menu JTA Search

Goldberg’s Top 50 goyim

The Atlantic’s Jeffrey Goldberg was recently listed by the Forward as one of America’s 50 most influential Jews. Well, Goldberg says, why shouldn’t there be a parallel list of Philo-Semites?

If the Forward can publish a list of the top 50 Jews, then Goldblog can publish a list of the top 50 philo-Semites. I don’t have a philosophical problem with this, by the way: I dissent from the line, first passed on to me by Frank Foer, who, tragically, is not a top-50 Jew (though his mother is!), that philo-Semites are anti-Semites who like Jews. So, a list, and one loyal readers can help me assemble.

Goldberg starts with five names: George Eliot, Barack Obama, Harry Truman, Emile Zola, Malcolm Gladwell.

A few thoughts… What was Harry Truman if not an anti-Semite who liked Jews (well, at least one Jew and the idea of a Jewish state)? Why Barack Obama and not Bill Clinton?

Here’s a few other possibilities: Jon Voight, George Will, John Hagee, David Gergen, Jean-Paul Sartre, Pope John Paul II.

Before we go on… I have a question for Goldberg: Would it help or hurt to stick to the Forward’s policy of limiting its list to living Americans?