Candlelighting, Readings:
Shabbat Candles: 8:05 p.m.
Torah: Numbers 30:2-32:42
Haftarah: Jeremiah 1:1-2:3
Havdalah: 9:05 p.m.
This week’s parashah contains one of the most troubling episodes in all of Torah.
Back in Numbers 25, the Israelites were caught “whoring” with Midianite (or Moabite) women, who introduced them to worshiping their god, Baal-Peor. It’s bad enough that the Midianite women are held responsible, not the Israelite men who actually did the “whoring.” But, to make matters worse, we see this week how an Israelite army inflicts revenge on the Midianites, by “killing every male” [Num. 31:7]. And to top it off, Moses (incensed that the women and children were spared) instructs the army to kill the captive male children and all females old enough for sexual relations because they might be among the women who introduced the idolatry [Num. 31:14-19].
I see no way to whitewash this passage. We should see it for what it is: a reflection of an era long ago when the biblical writers thought God might desire wholesale slaughter of entire populations as punishment for heresy. Such beliefs are still commonplace throughout areas of the world where pre-modern religious reactionaries still hold sway.
Most Jews, however, gave it up centuries ago. The Rabbis who inherited the biblical story as sacred writ (and could not, therefore, get rid of it) adopted the strategy of finding meaning in its details, while implicitly denying its character as a biblical mandate justifying slaughter.
One set of such lessons stands out.
Since one of the people killed was Balaam [Num. 31:8], Rashi reconsiders the Balaam narrative. Balaam had tried to destroy Israel by cursing them — by using words, that is; by contrast, Israel’s vengeance this week involves force of arms. This, says Rashi, is a reversal of roles, since words are the typically Jewish weapons, whereas armed warfare is normal among the nations where Jews lived. When Isaac blessed Esau, he correctly predicted the future by saying [Genesis 27:40], “By your sword you shall live,” whereas Isaac had said of Jacob, “The voice is the voice of Jacob” — and “voice” indicates words. Balaam had apparently co-opted the preferred Jewish weapon of words; the Israelites now turn the tables by adopting the usual weaponry of Balaam’s people: armed warfare.
Clearly, Rashi wants to distance Jews from any notion of military slaughter being the “usual” way that Jews do thing. Words, not war, are the proper Jewish strategy for getting on in the world. We do not murder people who disagree with us. We argue, negotiate, reason, plead, cajole, and then argue some more.
Rashi is not alone here. Midrash Tosefta makes the very same point.
They both know full well that the ideal Jew is a Talmudist, and Talmud is the honing of the mind through careful attention to words and the logic that connects them. The human march toward civilization is the upward path from physical violence to legal argumentation; we should be grateful to the Rabbis for their daring claim that God wants elegant argumentation, not violent brutality.
At the end of days, says Maimonides (echoing the view of Samuel in the Talmud) the world will continue as it is now — except that oppression will cease, and Jews will be free to study Torah. Weapons of violence will disappear; the infinite joy of verbal debate will not.
Until such time, however, Jews, too, have had to master warfare. Here is the tragedy of the Jewish state: it is the only country founded on Jewish values, to the point where Talmudic study receives special legal protection, but also the place where Jewish military might is regularly required. We all know Israelis who must repeatedly go to war but none of them glorify it. It is not the Jewish way.
Support the New York Jewish Week
Our nonprofit newsroom depends on readers like you. Make a donation now to support independent Jewish journalism in New York.
I give you Torah and mitzvot, God says,” that you may live by them.” We do not “live” by warfare, however much we must protect ourselves by mastering it. We “live” by the sacred play of words, by logic, argument, reason and by the sharpening of minds.
That’s the Jewish way now, as much as ever.
Rabbi Lawrence Hoffman, co-founder of Synagogue 3000, and professor of Liturgy, Worship and Ritual at the Hebrew Union College, is the author of “My People’s Prayer Book,” winner of the National Jewish Book Award for Modern Jewish Thought and Experience.
