Violence is on the Rise in Israel, and Bereaved Families Pay the Price
Menu JTA Search

Violence is on the Rise in Israel, and Bereaved Families Pay the Price

Download PDF for this date

“Suddenly I receive a telephone call: My brother, Avinoam, is dead. Impossible, I say to myself, Avinoam, my kid brother, murdered?” It was a lovely April day when the young couple went down to the popular Nirvana beach in Haifa with their two dogs for a stroll and a cup of coffee. It was the last day in the life of Avinoam Shoshan, 31. He was murdered, on the beach promenade, in front of hundreds of people.

Why? Because Shoshan’s dog got into a fight with another dog. It was too much of an insult for the owner of the other dog, so he pulled a knife and stabbed Shoshan to death.

Almost three years have passed, but Ziva Shulav, Shoshan’s sister, relives that day over and over again.

She was one of the key speakers at a December symposium on violence in the Israeli society, held in Haifa, organized by the municipality and the Ibn-Khaldoun Society for the Advancement of Democracy.

“Everyone talks about political terrorism,” Shulav said, “but people in Israel are also subject to civil terrorism, and this is often accepted as an inevitable divine punishment.”

“We talk a lot about the symptoms for this phenomenon, but not enough about the causes of violence,” said Gideon Fishman, head of Haifa University’s Minerva Center for the Study of Youth. “If we do not explore the causes, nothing will help, neither more policemen nor more punitive measures.”

The sociological explanations are numerous, and not necessarily well-founded. Some theories: Police and military brutality against Palestinians has spilled over to Israel proper, and is manifested by wilder driving habits and a propensity to violence; the large immigration from the Former Soviet Union has led to more alcoholism in Israel, thus raising the number of alcohol-related acts of violence; the abundance of drugs — according to government statistics, every 10th Israeli youth is exposed to drugs — helps instigate acts of violence.

Israelis adore America: They like to dress American-style and are addicted to American cinema, junk food and music. But until a few years ago, stories of violence in America were dismissed as something that “could not happen here.”

No more. Stories such as Shoshan’s murder have become a matter of routine. According to police, in the northern part of the country alone a murder takes place every seven and a half days, a rape every 10 days, a bodily assault every 30 minutes.

On the national level, police last year recorded a rise of 3.2 percent in physical violence, following five years of continuous decrease. An increase of 4.9 percent was reported in cases of violence against minors.

Some 18.5 percent of crimes in the first six months of 2005 were crimes of violence, compared to 17.3 percent in the same period last year. Police have opened 15,606 files on suspicion of violence, compared to 13,253 last year.

Tzahi Ya’acov, 16, was stabbed to death last February in the middle of a mall because he drew the attention of another minor to a 100 shekel bill — about $25 — on the shelf of a shoe store.

“I want to see the man who will dare touch this bill,” said the youth, and his friend went over to Tzahi and stabbed him. The prosecution last week reached a bargain plea with the defense, downgrading the charges from murder to manslaughter.

Other stories abound: Ronni Ruhana, 41, of the Arab village of Issfiya near Haifa, was gunned down by a neighbor, a border policeman, because Ruhana’s brother had separated from the neighbor’s sister and refused to pay the alimony demanded.

A recent survey conducted by Haifa University’s sociology department showed that out of 800 interviewees — half Arab, half Jewish — some 38 percent said the level of violence has increased in their neighborhoods.

In addition, 45 percent said anyone can easily get a weapon, though possession of arms in Israel is strictly licensed, and 72 percent said punishment of violent criminals is too light.

There was one hopeful finding in the survey: Only 3 percent of respondents said they had experienced violence themselves. The figure was slightly higher — 5 percent– among Arab respondents.

“These are more or less the figures,” Police Commander Dov Lutzky, deputy commander of the northern police command, told JTA. “Violence is on an upward trend, but it’s not as dramatic as it may seem listening to testimonies in the symposium.”

“The worst case of violence is in the Arab sector,” said lawyer Sylvia Freiman, the district attorney for northern Israel. “Arabs often have a mentality of ‘we’ and ‘them,’ and refuse to seek the help of the police.”

Dr., As’ad Ghanem, head of the Ibn-Khaldoun Association said he no longer reprimands young drivers who drive too fast, because “I’m afraid they will come out and beat me with a club.”

Ziva Shulav and other bereaved families have set up a society of “Families of Murder Victims,” similar to groups in the United States and United Kingdom.

“They have societies for terror victims, they have societies for women who were subject to violence, they have societies for the rehabilitation of prisoners, but the state has forgotten the victims of regular everyday violence. These families remain on their own,” said Lara Zinneman of Haifa, whose daughter Ganit was murdered 10 years ago by an American student at Haifa University. “The society is obsessively preoccupied with the murderer, but ignores the victims and his family.”

The only mention of political violence in the symposium came from a Moslem religious leader. Sheikh Mohammad Sharif Ouda is head of the Ahmadiyya community in Haifa, a small community that is strictly anti-violence.

“I accuse religious education of encouraging violence,” Ouda told JTA. “Moslem children hear of jihad in school, Christians carry the heavy burden of the Inquisition’s heritage, and Jews say ‘spill your rage onto the gentiles.’ “

Ziva Shulav says that when she attended the shiva for Mayan Sapir, a 15-year-old who was murdered and raped by a 16-year-old in Rishon Lezion, Sapir’s mother begged Shulav’s forgiveness.

” ‘When I read about your brother’s murder,’ she said, ‘I felt sorry for the family, but just like everyone else I continued to go about my business. I beg for forgiveness for having failed to get up and cry in protest,’ ” Shulav recalled. “Murder and violence are no longer a matter for the criminal world only; it has become a problem for every family in Israel.”

Shoshan’s murderer was sentenced to 18 years in jail. In the Ruhana murder, the verdict is be handed down soon — but for now the murderer’s father still walks around his village, proudly waving his gun.

Founding Funders

The digitization of the JTA Archive would not have been possible without the generous support of the following donors:
  • The Gottesman Fund
  • Righteous Persons Foundation
  • Charles H. Revson Foundation
  • Elisa Spungen Bildner and Robert Bildner, in honor of Norma Spungen
  • George S. Blumenthal
  • Grace and Scott Offen Charitable Fund