Below is the full list of winners of the 32nd Annual Simon Rockower Awards for Excellence in Jewish Journalism:
Category 1: The Louis Rapoport Award for Excellence in Commentary
Division A. Newspapers 15,000 circulation and over; all Magazines/Web-Based Outlets
- First Place: New Jersey Jewish News, Whippany, N.J.
“Heaven can wait,” “Washed out,” “Speak politics the Jewish way” by Andrew Silow-Carroll
Comments: Insight mixed with great humor and impeccable style.
- Second Place: j. the Jewish news weekly of Northern California, San Francisco
“Be a Jew, go to the movies,” “Prayer, there’s an app for that,” “Forgotten heroes of a long ago war“by Sue Fishkoff
Comments: Smart and incisive takes on quirky slices of life.
Division B. Newspapers 14,999 circulation and under.
- First Place: Intermountain Jewish News, Denver
“Black hole and the light of faith” by Hillel Goldberg
Comments: Three eloquent essays that combine brilliant style with forceful advocacy.
- Second Place: The Rockland Jewish Federation Reporter, West Nyack, N.Y.
“The canary in the coal mine,” “Not so different, yet worlds apart,” “Just one minute” by Marla Cohen
Comments: Insightful and well written personal commentary.
Category 2: Award for Excellence in Single Commentary
Division A. Newspapers 15,000 circulation and over; all Magazines/Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: Hadassah Magazine, New York
“Letter from Jerusalem: Triage for founding values” by Gershom Gorenberg
Comments: Excellent analysis of Israel’s past and future struggle for its domestic identity – and extremely well written. Incisive historical perspective, yet very forward-looking. Great use of Jared Diamond, and a wonderful play on words in the all-important closing paragraph.
- Second Place: Jewish Standard, Teaneck, N.J.
“Obama’s distorted Israel image” by Shammai Engelmayer
Comments: It is a well-executed political commentary.
Division B. Newspapers 14,999 circulation and under.
- First Place: The Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle, Milwaukee
“We want to be inclusive, but you must want to be included” by Leon Cohen
Comments: The author provides a declaration of what a Jewish newspaper should be to the community.
- Second Place: Intermountain Jewish News, Denver
“What they didn’t tell me on my bar mitzvah” by Hillel Goldberg
Comments: Nice personal thoughts.
Category 3: Award for Excellence in Personal Essay
Division A. Newspapers 15,000 circulation and over; all Magazines/Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: Ruth Ebenstein, Jerusale (Published in Tablet Magazine)
“Brought together by cancer: Israeli and Palestinian breast-cancer survivors build camaraderie as we face a common enemy” by Ruth Ebenstein
- Second Place: JTA
“Dressing like my Jewish mother” by Edmon J. Rodman
Division B. Newspapers 14,999 circulation and under.
- First Place: Jewish Independent, Vancouver
“In honor of those murdered” by Karen James - Second Place: The Jewish Journal (North of Boston), Salem, Mass.
“A new feeling” by Peter Nathan
Category 4: Award for Excellence in Editorial Writing
Division A. Newspapers 15,000 circulation and over; all Magazines/Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: The Canadian Jewish News, North York, Ontario
“Expel Iran from UN,” “Israel must uphold the law,” “Israel should investigate” by Mordechai Ben-Dat
Comments: These are well-argued, well-written editorials that have the courage of their convictions, even when the object of criticism is the Jewish community itself.
- Second Place: j. the Jewish news weekly of Northern California, San Francisco
“Ode to a Kitchen Table,” “Anat Hoffman arrest at Wall is a shanda,” “Tit-for-tat provocations impede peace”
Division B. Newspapers 14,999 circulation and under.
- First Place: Jewish Independent, Vancouver
“Focusing on motives,” “Four other questions,” “Jerusalem: A Jewish city” by staff
- Second Place: St. Louis Jewish Light, St. Louis
“A Tal order,” “Antidisestablishmentarianism,” “The hate state” by Larry Levin and Robert A. Cohn
Category 5: The Boris Smolar Award for Excellence in Enterprise or Investigative Reporting
Division A. Newspapers 15,000 circulation and over; all Magazines/Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: JTA, New York
“Can Greg Schneider steer the Claims Conference past a $57m fraud?” by Uriel Heilman
- Second Place: j. the Jewish news weekly of Northern California, San Francisco
“Jewish at U.C: the real report, by students themselves” by Dan Pine
Division B. Newspapers 14,999 circulation and under.
- First Place: The Boiling Point, Los Angeles
“Jewish life is improving at UCs” by Tamar Willis
Category 6: Award for Excellence in News Reporting
Division A. Newspapers 15,000 circulation and over; all Magazines/Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: Jewish Standard, Teaneck, N.J.
“Love and hate in Bergen County” by Larry Yudelson, Charles Zusman, Josh Lipowsky and Abigail Klein Leichman
- Second Place: The Jewish Week, New York
“Has the ‘Tough Love’ rebbe gone too far?” by Gary Rosenblatt and Yedidya Gorsetman
Division B. Newspapers 14,999 circulation and under.
- First Place: Chicago Jewish News, Skokie
“Campus showdown” by Pauline Yearwood
Comments: Strong reporting gave new insight to a complicated fight within Chicago’s Jewish community. The story explained the issue from all sides with clarity.
- Second Place:Intermountain Jewish News, Denver
“Is marijuana kosher?” by Chris Leppek
Comments: An interesting take on an issue that was in the news statewide, this story raised new questions and brought in a wide range of opinion.
Category 7: Award for Excellence in Feature Writing
Division A. Newspapers 15,000 circulation and over.
- First Place: Hamodia, Brooklyn, New York
“The lost Jewish world – A visit to contemporary Lithuania” by Evelyne Singer and Ruth Lichtenstein
Comments: A well-researched, well-reported and deeply felt look at a lost Jewish world. It showed, in heart-breaking detail, the vitality of that community, how little is left today and the horror of what happened in between.
- Second Place: JTA, New York
“For Jewish Deadheads, the music never stopped” by Chavie Lieber
Comments: A thorough and well-written look at yet another of the myriad ways to be Jewish today. Informative, vividly reported and a delight to read.
Division B. Newspapers from 7,500 to 14,999 circulation.
- First Place: Chicago Jewish News, Skokie
“Savers of the lost ark” by Pauline Yearwood
- Second Place: Intermountain Jewish News, Denver
“Cremation vs. burial: the final act” by Andrea Jacobs
Division C. Newspapers from 1-7,499 circulation.
- First Place: Jewish Independent, Vancouver
“What Hebrew do we speak?” by Nurit Dekel
- Second Place: Yiddish Forward, New York
“Inside Hasidic modesty patrols” by Rukhl Schaechter (in English)
Division D. Magazines/Special Sections and Supplements/Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: Hadassah Magazine, New York
“A legacy in harmony” by Tom Tugend
- Second Place: Jewish Action (Orthodox Union), New York
“Striking a balance: Work & family” by Barbara Bensoussan, Azriela Jaffe, Tova Ross, Nechama Carmel and Rashel Zywica
Category 8: Award for Excellence in Arts and Criticism News and Features
Division A. Critical analysis/review, usually of a single artistic endeavor, whether in literature, theater, film or fine arts and crafts. All Newspapers and Magazine/Special Sections and Supplements/Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: Jewish News of Greater Phoenix, Phoenix, AZ
“Dylan, Cohen: Loins in winter” by Salvatore Caputo
Comments: The writing here flows with such natural fluidity, it is irresistible. The writer displays a deep knowledge of his subjects and impressive critical skills.
- Second Place: JTA, New York
“Is HBO’s ‘Girls’ about young women’s struggles, or some women’s privileges?” by Dvora Meyers
Comments: Superlative writing and trenchant critical comments. Particularly strong opening paragraph and closing sentence.
Division B. Reporting on an artistic endeavor, trend, movement or personality, whether in literature, theater, film or fine arts and crafts. All Newspapers and Magazine/Special Sections and Supplements/Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: Intermountain Jewish News, Denver
“The victory of Jewish music over evil” by Andrea Jacobs
Comments: A beautifully written profile of a man, a choral group and the role of music in both Jewish liturgy and the Holocaust. The writer’s emotional and intellectual engagement with the subject is obvious. This story told me things I didn’t know, and made me want to learn more.
- Second Place: Na’amat Woman, New York
“Helene Aylon” by Judith A. Sokoloff
Comments: This is a smart, sophisticated and admirably in-depth profile of an artist who both uses Judaism and questions Judaism in her work.
Category 9: The David Frank Award for Excellence in Personality Profiles
Division A. Newspapers 15,000 circulation and over.
First Place: j. the Jewish news weekly of Northern California, San Francisco
“Road to atonement” by Alix Wall
Comments: What struck me about this story was the breadth of reporting. The reporter tried to contact the victim’s family; she spoke to people who knew him in prison, etc.
Second Place: Jewish Exponent, Philadelphia
“His central business: Peace among people” by Bryan Schwartzman
Comments: Fascinating story. Flows smoothly and well reported.
Division B. Newspapers 14,999 circulation and under.
- First Place: JTNews, Seattle
“Chief rabbi’s visit unites community” by Emily K. Alhadeff
- Second Place: Intermountain Jewish News, Denver
“Hadassah’s founder: The lonely and courageous life of Henrietta Szold” by Hillel Goldberg
Division C. Magazines/Special Sections and Supplements/Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: Hadassah Magazine, New York
“Profile: Amos Oz” by Rahel Musleah
- Second Place: Hadassah Magazine, New York
“Profile: Laila Abed Rabho” by Shoshana London Sappir
Category 10: Award for Excellence in Special Sections or Supplements
Division A: Newspapers 15,000 circulation and over.
- First Place: Hamodia, Brooklyn, New York
“Hurricane Sandy” by staff and Ruth Lichtenstein
Division B. Newspapers 14,999 circulation and under.
- First Place: Jewish Voice, Wilmington
“Shalom Delaware” by Seth J. Katzen, Carolyn Katwan and Shoshana Martyniak
- Second Place: St. Louis Jewish Light, St. Louis
“Israel alive” by Ellen Futterman, Mike Sherwin, Richard Weiss and Larry Levin
Division C. Magazines.
- First Place: Hadassah Magazine, New York
August/September – Centennial issue by Alan M. Tigay
Category 11: Award for Excellence in Organizational Newsletters
Division A. Organizational Hard Copy.
- First Place: NCSY, New York
Ignite – Spring (Passover) 2012 by Duvi Stahler, Tova Flancbaum and Scott Saunders
Comments: Your compelling stories, particularly the “Spotlights” section, and bright colors convey energy and likely will appeal to your target audience.
Division B. eNewsletter.
- First Place: Intermountain Jewish News, Denver
IJN Weekly eNewsletter by Shana Goldberg
Comments: Your front pages are laid out well for easy scanning by readers, without scrolling down a long page. Concise teasers lead to feature story pages via “read more” buttons, and sidebars offer additional news, community calendar etc. Very user friendly!
Category 12: Award for Excellence in Writing About Women
- First Place: Hadassah Magazine, New York
“Family Matters: Pure and prosaic” by Miriam Karp
Comments: Karp’s is a beautiful, spiritual, personal essay about completing tahara – ritual purification of the deceased – for the first time. Her pacing is exquisite, her tone is deeply respectful, and her account is marked by lovely attention to detail. Karp’s experience, and her meditation on it, leaves the reader awed.
- Second Place: The Boiling Point, Los Angeles
“Going solo: New view of ‘kol isha’ lets girls sing on their own” by Rebecca Mandel
Comments: Mandel explores in a thorough, informative and sensitive way the tension between tradition and change at a coed Modern Orthodox day school in L.A. By describing from every angle the school’s decision to allow women to sing solos, in contravention of traditional Orthodox interpretations of a Biblical phrase, she makes an otherwise hard-to-grasp issue accessible to non-Orthodox readers. Her story resonates at a time when Jewish women in the U.S. and Israel are seeking a greater voice in religious affairs, and her reporting and storytelling skills impress.
Category 13: The Jacob Rader Marcus Award for Journalistic Excellence in American Jewish History
Division A. Newspapers 15,000 circulation and over; all Magazines/Special Sections and Supplements/Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: B’nai B’rith Magazine, Washington
“Jews in the Southern struggle for civil rights: Letting justice roll down” by Dina Weinstein
- Second Place: Hamodia, Brooklyn, New York
“The Jewish Consumptives Relief Society” by Devorah Klein and Ruth Lichtenstein
Division B. Newspapers 14,999 circulation and under.
- First Place: The Dayton Jewish Observer, Centerville, Ohio
“Kosher Titanic — and other Jewish connections to the ill-fated liner” by Marshall Weiss
http://www.jewishdayton.org/observer/jewish-connections-to-titanic/
http://www.jewishdayton.org/observer/kosher-titanic/
http://www.jewishdayton.org/observer/lost-found-at-sea/
http://www.jewishdayton.org/observer/kosher-deli-in-england-a-titanic-survivor’s-legacy/
http://www.jewishdayton.org/observer/at-halifax’s-jewish-cemetery-a-titanic-section/
- Second Place: Intermountain Jewish News, Denver
“Hadassah’s founder: The lonely and courageous life of Henrietta Szold” by Hillel Goldberg
Category 14: Award for Excellence in Overall Graphic Design
Division A. Newspapers 15,000 circulation and over.
- First Place: j. the Jewish news weekly of Northern California, San Francisco
January 6, February 24 and November 23, 2012 issues of j. weekly by Cathleen Maclearie
Division B. Newspapers 14,999 circulation and under.
- First Place: Baltimore Jewish Times, Owings Mill, Md.
April 20, October 5 and October 19 issues by Lindsey Bridwell
Division C. Magazines/Special Sections and Supplements/Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: Hadassah Magazine, New York
June/July, August/September and October/November issues by Jodie Berzin Rossi
Category 15: Award for Excellence in Graphic Design: COVER
Division A. Magazines. Submit one (1) cover for the contest year.
- First Place: NCSY, New York
Ignite – Fall (Rosh Hashanah) 2012 Issue by Duvi Stahler, Tova Flancbaum, Michael Orbach, Andres Moncayo and Benji Cheirif
Comments: Excellent photo choice, restrained design. Matching the color in the masthead to the photo is a nice touch.
Division B. Newspapers (encompasses weekly and non-weekly newspapers). Submit three (3) covers from the contest year.
- First Place: j. the Jewish news weekly of Northern California, San Francisco
May 4, October 12 and December 14, 2012 covers by Cathleen Maclearie
Comments: j.’s covers are always designed with style and grace.
- Second Place: Chicago JUF News, Chicago
May, July and September 2012 covers by Alyssa Zeller
Category 16: The Noah Bee Award for Excellence in Illustrating and/or Editorial Cartooning
Division A. Cartoons.
- First Place: Steve Greenberg, Burbank, Cali.
“Greenberg’s View”
http://58028505f9d0490e239d-dd278761b79c5ed7a0a13a08da51440a.r34.cf2.rackcdn.com/173787759250efa0c12b7aa_0.jpg
http://58028505f9d0490e239d-dd278761b79c5ed7a0a13a08da51440a.r34.cf2.rackcdn.com/130075725950efa0c1353ec_1.jpg
http://58028505f9d0490e239d-dd278761b79c5ed7a0a13a08da51440a.r34.cf2.rackcdn.com/105770554050efa0c137b05_2.jpg
Division B. Illustrations.
- First Place: Hadassah Magazine, New York
August/September, October/November and December/January issues by Koren Shadmi and Andy Potts
http://58028505f9d0490e239d-dd278761b79c5ed7a0a13a08da51440a.r34.cf2.rackcdn.com/207106265050f965b25e1ff_0.pdf
http://58028505f9d0490e239d-dd278761b79c5ed7a0a13a08da51440a.r34.cf2.rackcdn.com/100970613850f965b26090b_1.pdf
http://58028505f9d0490e239d-dd278761b79c5ed7a0a13a08da51440a.r34.cf2.rackcdn.com/1761757250f965b26572b_2.pdf
Comments: A nice range of illustrations, sensitively drawn and well presented.
Category 17: Award for Excellence in Photography
Division A. All Newspapers.
- First Place: The Dayton Jewish Observer, Centerville, Ohio
“Keeping the faith…every day” by Marshall Weiss
- Second Place: Jewish Herald-Voice, Houston
Cover photo of rabbi by Michael Duke
Division B. Magazines/Special Sections and Supplements/Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: Hadassah Magazine, New York
“Suited for action,” June/July cover by Debbie Zimelman
Category 18: Award for Outstanding Website
Division A. Newspapers 15,000 circulation and over.
- First Place: Jewish Exponent, Philadelphia
www.jewishexponent.com
Division B. Newspapers 14,999 circulation and under.
- First Place: St. Louis Jewish Light, St. Louis
www.stljewishlight.com by Mike Sherwin, Agatha Gallagher and Tom Wombacher
Division D. Web-Based Outlets.
- First Place: My Jewish Learning, New York
- Second Place: InterfaithFamily.com, Newton Upper Falls, Mass.
www.InterfaithFamily.com by Benjamin Maron, Heather Martin and Ed Case
Category 19: Award for Excellence in a Multi-Media Story
Division A. Jewish Media News Outlets.
- First Place: JTA, New York
“Holy hoops — The story of the Beren Academy basketball team” by Uri Fintzy
Comments: This was a timely and well produced video report from JTA.
Division B. Jewish Organizations.
- First Place: Jewish National Fund, New York
“Positively Israel” by Megan Taylor and Ezra Chasser
Comments: This website used many multimedia elements to tell its story, including an annotated map, videos and links for people to take action.
Category 20: Award for Excellence in Blogging
- First Place: JTA, New York
“Capital J” by Ron Kampeas
Comments: Ron Kampeas rocks the blog format: his writing is warm and conversational, informal, but still always thoughtful. It’s creative — using text and images and video — and still has the kind of precision you hear in good jazz improv.
- Second Place: Chicago JUF News, Chicago
“That’s Feminist, with a Capital ‘F,’” “Training the Black Dog,” “Progress” by Linda Haase
Comments: I just loved Linda Haase’s pieces: her posts, like many of the best blogs, are highly first-person subjective, but unlike many of the worst, are not a festival of narcissistic TMI. She’s a really fine writer and I’ll look for her in the future.
