Search JTA's historical archive dating back to 1923

Gay Yeshiva Students Lose Appeal in Lawsuit to Share Student Housing

May 16, 2000
See Original Daily Bulletin From This Date

Gay and lesbian students, having lost the latest round in their legal battle with the nation’s oldest and largest Jewish university, are vowing to take the case to New York’s highest court.

The vow came after the appellate division of the New York State Supreme Court denied an appeal by two lesbian students and the gay and lesbian student organization claiming that Yeshiva University’s Albert Einstein College of Medicine discriminates by barring same-sex couples from its married student housing.

The plaintiffs, backed by the American Civil Liberties Union, sued the Bronx, N.Y., medical school in 1998.

Yeshiva University is commonly thought of as an Orthodox institution, but – – except for its Orthodox rabbinical school — it is nonsectarian and thus must comply with all anti-discrimination laws.

The case against Yeshiva was dismissed last year, and earlier this month, the appellate division ruled that the university’s policy does not have a disparate impact on homosexuals.

The medical school issued a statement that the court’s decision “speaks for itself.”

“We have maintained all along that our student housing policies are fair and nondiscriminatory,” the statement continued.

However, the associate director of the ACLU’s Lesbian and Gay Rights Project, which is arguing on behalf of the students, called the recent decision “ridiculous” and said the students would appeal to the state’s highest court, the New York Court of Appeals.

“The basic grounds for the appeal is the decision is wrong and it defies all logic and common sense to state, as this court did, that requiring a marriage certificate for housing affects gay couples the same as unmarried heterosexual couples,” said Michael Adams.

Sara Levin and Maggie Jones, the two students who, along with the medical school’s gay and lesbian organization, are plaintiffs in the case, did not return calls requesting comment.

Gay and lesbian students at the university, like other students, are eligible for university housing, but their nonstudent partners are not. The students had claimed that the practice of requiring marriage certificates for nonstudent partners was discriminatory because homosexual couples are unable to marry and thus cannot be eligible.

New York City anti-discrimination laws prohibit any policies that have a disparate impact on homosexuals.

However, the university maintained that since unmarried heterosexual couples are also not eligible for housing, the policy equally affects gay and heterosexual students.

In dismissing their case in the New York State Supreme Court in March of 1999, the judge, Franklin Weissberg, wrote that the university is not responsible for the fact that gay and lesbian students are unable to legally marry.

“The plaintiffs’ real complaint lies not with the defendants but, rather, with the refusal of the New York State Legislature to sanction same-sex marriages,” wrote Weissberg.

EDITORS: The following is a revised color story on the Million Mom March, with additional reporting from events around the country. Please note the last name of the rabbi from Hawaii is Magid, not Magie.

Recommended from JTA