Orthodox Groups Voice United Stance Against Religious Pluralism
Menu JTA Search

Orthodox Groups Voice United Stance Against Religious Pluralism

Download PDF for this date

In their strongest and most unified public stance to date about religious pluralism and Jewish unity, four major American Orthodox organizations have issued a joint High Holiday statement condemning those who have challenged Israel’s religious status quo.

In the statement titled “A heartfelt message to our fellow Jews,” the four groups — Agudath Israel of America, the National Council of Young Israel, the Rabbinical Council of America and the Orthodox Union — confirm their commitment to a single halachic standard in Israel and implore all Jews “to shun unworthy political posturing, as well as political, economic and social pressure.”

Leaders of the same four Orthodox groups met in a closed session with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in New York in the spring, urging him to maintain Orthodox control over these matters in Israel.

But this is the first time in memory that they have issued this type of joint public statement.

Referring obliquely to lawsuits brought by Reform and Conservative Jews who want to have their non-Orthodox conversions and marriages legally recognized by Israeli — as well as to pressure placed on Israeli government officials by religiously liberal American Jewish leaders — the statement blames those who have attacked the Orthodox-controlled religious establishment for having “created a climate of ill-will and anger.”

“All Jews, regardless of level of religious observance or affiliation, should recognize that there must be uniformly acceptable Jewish standards for religious marriage, divorce and conversion if the integrity of our peoplehood is to be preserved,” the statement says.

Referring directly to Israel’s local religious councils in which Reform and Conservative Jews have sought the legal right to participate, the statement calls it “only reasonable” that all members of municipal religious councils in Israel “subscribe to the religious precepts that they are charged to oversee.”

The statement also says that it is “a matter of historical fact” that the Western Wall “has been a sacred place of traditional Jewish prayer and peace and tranquility for Jews since time immemorial.”

On Shavuot and again more recently on Tisha B’Av, Conservative and Reform men and women attempting to pray together at the Wall were chased away from the site — the first time by a mob of angry haredi, or devoutly Orthodox Jews, and in August by Jerusalem police, who insisted that they could not be protected.

The statement says that for American Jewish leaders to “attempt to impose their own parochial wishes on an Israeli public that has expressed its stance clearly and democratically is both divisive and wrong.”

Leaders of the Reform and Conservative movement here criticized the statement.

Rabbi Eric Yoffie, president of the Reform movement’s Union of American Hebrew Congregations, said it “is out of touch with the realities both in Israel and here.”

Calling Israel “a spiritual wasteland,” Yoffie said, “It’s not about preserving the integrity of Jewish peoplehood, but about preserving control of the Orthodox monopoly over religious life in Israel.”

Added Rabbi Ismar Schorsch, chancellor of the Conservative movement’s Jewish Theological Seminary: “Religious pluralism works for Jews in America; why should it be denied to Jews in Israel?”

Founding Funders

The digitization of the JTA Archive would not have been possible without the generous support of the following donors:
  • The Gottesman Fund
  • Righteous Persons Foundation
  • Charles H. Revson Foundation
  • Elisa Spungen Bildner and Robert Bildner, in honor of Norma Spungen
  • George S. Blumenthal
  • Grace and Scott Offen Charitable Fund