Behind the Headlines: Being Jewish in Germany’s Army; Experience Reflects Neo- Nazi Acts
Menu JTA Search

Behind the Headlines: Being Jewish in Germany’s Army; Experience Reflects Neo- Nazi Acts

Download PDF for this date

When David Meyer asked whether he would be able to keep kosher and go on leave for the Jewish High Holidays while serving in the German army, the head of the recruiting board accused him of holding up the proceedings.

And the situation only worsened after the 19-year-old joined his unit in the army, known as the Bundeswehr.

Not only was no kosher or vegetarian food available, World War II helmets and photographs adorned some offices, and Meyer was punished when he asked to be excused from attending a Christian service.

“I really believed that the generational change had done away with Nazi attitudes and that the Bundeswehr could not afford such things to happen,” he says. “But after the events of the past two months, my trust in the Bundeswehr has reached rock bottom.”

Meyer’s experience offers a personal lens on the recent neo-Nazi scandals that have rocked the German army.

Some 160 neo-Nazi events were reported this year in the German army, according to a parliamentary army ombudsman. Among them:

Several amateur videos appeared, filmed by German soldiers, showing other soldiers demonstrating pro-Nazi actions, including shouts of “Heil Hitler”;

A German magazine reported that recruits in army barracks regularly celebrate Hitler’s birthday;

A 21-year-old who just completed his army service, Christian Krause, told a German tabloid in December that soldiers routinely made comments such as “the Jews must be gassed.”

Krause also claimed it was easy in his unit to order right-wing propaganda material printed in Denmark and said some soldiers with whom he served were involved in other right-wing activities;

German Defense Ministry officials have confirmed that a well-known neo-Nazi, Manfred Roeder, delivered a lecture at an German army officers training school in 1995.

With the support of Chancellor Helmut Kohl, the ministry has launched an investigation into neo-Nazism in the army. After conducting an internal investigation into Krause’s charges, the ministry said it had found that only a few soldiers out of those it interviewed backed up his claims.

The ministry has also maligned Krause for not coming forward sooner.

Defense Minister Volker Ruehe argues that “these mistakes reflect neither the spirit of the troops nor everyday life in our armed forces.”

Opposition politicians have charged that the government, through its attacks on Krause, is trying to discourage other soldiers from reporting neo-Nazi incidents.

For Meyer, the situation peaked when he asked for leave to celebrate Rosh Hashanah, and an officer told him that he should throw the application away.

“I was so furious about the way he talked because I could have been told in a friendly way,” Meyer says.

In response, his father, Hans, wrote a letter to the defense minister, asking him to grant “those minimum rights that a German of Jewish belief is entitled to.”

While army officials investigated the matter, David Meyer was summoned to two interrogations in which he was told to consider the future career of his superiors and retract his accusations.

The ministry’s investigation into the matter showed that the local recruiting office had never passed on the directive that accommodations should be made to help Meyer practice his Judaism.

Michael Fuerst, responsible for army matters within the Central Council of Jews in Germany, attributed Meyer’s experience to “ignorance” on the part of superiors.

In a letter to the Defense Ministry, Fuerst recently regretted that discussions about the sensitivity needed to be shown Jews in the military “do not seem to have got down to lower ranks.”

Still, Fuerst says: “You cannot say the Bundeswehr is anti-Semitic because we have anti-Semitic incidents.”

Although Germany has a draft army, Jewish citizens are exempted from service if their parents or grandparents are Holocaust survivors.

However, with the recent surge in the German Jewish population and a growing sense that Jews will be able to live safely in Germany, some young German Jews are choosing army service.

The Jewish community is negotiating with the army about the possibility of offering recruits kosher meals as well as the services of an army chaplain.

Meanwhile, Meyer’s request to be transferred to the military unit in his home town of Muenster was eventually granted, and he describes the situation there as more tolerant.

Nevertheless, he counts the days until April, when his military service will end.

Founding Funders

The digitization of the JTA Archive would not have been possible without the generous support of the following donors:
  • The Gottesman Fund
  • Righteous Persons Foundation
  • Charles H. Revson Foundation
  • Elisa Spungen Bildner and Robert Bildner, in honor of Norma Spungen
  • George S. Blumenthal
  • Grace and Scott Offen Charitable Fund