Search JTA's historical archive dating back to 1923

Report: Israel, Palestinians Commit ‘serious’ Rights Abuses

February 4, 1998
See Original Daily Bulletin From This Date

Israel and the Palestinian Authority continue to commit “serious human rights abuses,” according to the annual U.S. State Department report on human rights.

The voluminous account on virtually every country in the world chronicles everything from deaths in police custody to rights of women and the disabled.

“You’ll find evidence of human rights abuses in both Israel and the territories,” John Shattuck, U.S. assistant secretary of state for democracy and human rights, said in a briefing on the report.

While Israel generally respects human rights, the report says, the country sometimes mistreats Palestinian detainees.

Tying the incidence of human rights abuses to movement in the peace process, the report says that Israel’s main problems over the years have arisen from “policies and practices in the occupied territories and from its fight against terrorism.”

The Israeli redeployments from the West Bank and Gaza “have significantly reduced the scope of these problems,” the report says.

According to the State Department, one Palestinian was killed while in Israeli detention in 1997, compared with two deaths in 1996.

Seven detainees died in Palestinian prisons, including two who the Palestinian Authority said died after being tortured, according to the report. In 1996, four Palestinians died while in custody.

Neither Israeli nor Palestinian officials were available to comment on the report.

While this report does not focus on all terrorist incidents — a separate U.S. report issued later in the year does — it does mention the 24 victims killed in suicide bombings after the Palestinians “slackened security cooperation” following the start of Israeli construction at Har Homa, a development in southeastern Jerusalem.

For their part, Israeli troops killed 10 Palestinian demonstrators, including a deaf and mentally impaired 14-year-old boy in Gaza and an 8-year-old boy in Bethlehem, according to the report.

Based on information provided by U.S. embassies around the world, the report is usually respected for its accuracy — and often attacked by U.S. allies for its analysis.

But this year, one part of the report’s accuracy is being called into question.

After listing the names of Palestinian youths killed during clashes with Israeli troops in the section on the West Bank and Gaza, including areas under Palestinian control, the report states, “No Israeli civilians or security personnel were killed or seriously wounded by [Palestinian] demonstrators.”

However, there were at least 35 incidents where Israelis were injured by Palestinians during demonstrations, many seriously, according to news clippings gathered by the Zionist Organization of America.

In one incident on July 1, Palestinian protesters threw pipe bombs at Israeli soldiers in Hebron.

“In an anguishing scene caught on videotape, two Israeli soldiers fell screaming to the ground and left a thick trail of blood as medics carried them away,” The Washington Post reported on July 5.

State Department officials could not immediately comment on the apparent discrepancies, but the issue was expected to be raised by Jewish activists at a Wednesday briefing with Shattuck.

The apparent discrepancy comes on the heels of the release of another State Department report that includes a “serious policy gaffe,” according to a State Department official who spoke on the condition that he not be identified.

The Jan. 23 interim report on worldwide religious persecution names “Palestine” as a country.

In a partial list of some of the conflicts in which religion is a factor, the report includes “Bosnia, Northern Ireland, and Israel-Palestine.”

Meanwhile, on the larger issue of religious freedom, three prominent American religious leaders are preparing to travel to China next week to observe and discuss the climate for religious freedom there.

One of the delegates appointed by President Clinton, Rabbi Arthur Schneier, president of the Appeal of Conscience Foundation, said he plans to raise the issue of recognizing Judaism as an official religion during meetings with China’s president, Jiang Zemin, and other top officials.

China has brushed aside the issue in the past, saying it has no Jews, but Schneier said the issue now has acquired greater importance because of Hong Kong’s Jewish population.

The delegation, including the Rev. Don Argue, president of the National Association of Evangelicals, and Theodore McCarrick, archbishop of Newark, met this week with President Clinton and Sandy Berger, the national security adviser, in advance of their trip, which grew out of last year’s U.S.-China summit.

Remaining otherwise tight-lipped about their specific agenda, Schneier said, “We’re not looking to this mission as a one-time event. It’s the beginning of a process.”

Recommended from JTA