Discovery of Colon Cancer Gene Sparks Jewish Alarm – and Questions
Menu JTA Search

Discovery of Colon Cancer Gene Sparks Jewish Alarm – and Questions

Download PDF for this date

The discovery that a genetic mutation relatively common among Ashkenazi Jews makes them predisposed to colon cancer has prompted alarm — and the search for more information.

“We’ve been flooded with calls,” said Jill Brensinger, a genetic counselor at John Hopkins University’s Hereditary Colorectal Cancer Registry in Baltimore.

Her department’s telephone message apologizes for long-term busy signals.

Researchers at Hopkins found that a genetic defect which doubles a person’s risk of colon cancer is present in about 360,000 American Jews, or 6 percent of the population, making it the most common cancer-causing mutation ever identified in an ethnic population.

Jews of Ashkenazi, or Eastern European, heritage, comprise 95 percent of the more than 5 million Jews in the United States.

Colon cancer is the third most common type of cancer in the United States and will likely kill about 55,000 men and women this year.

The new finding raises questions about why so many genetic mutations are being found in the Ashkenazi Jewish population. It also raises questions about the value and risks of genetic testing, especially for a disease that is often preventable.

The discovery was made by a team of researchers at the Howard Hughes Medical Institute of Johns Hopkins University. The findings appears in the September issue of the journal Nature Genetics.

The scientists analyzed blood and tissue samples taken from about 1,000 Ashkenazi Jews and concluded that Jews who carry the genetic mutation have double the odds — a 16 to 30 percent chance — of other Ashkenazi Jews of getting colon cancer.

Some in the health field warned of over-estimating the chances of Ashkenazi Jews getting colon cancer, citing initial reports that mutations BRCA1 and BRCA2 conferred a 70 to 80 percent chance of Jews with those genes getting breast cancer.

Those estimates were reduced in more recent studies, which put the rate at closer to 50 percent.

This finding marks the third time in as many years that Ashkenazi Jews have been singled out with discoveries about genetic mutations causing potentially fatal diseases. The two other discoveries both revolved around breast cancer genes.

“I have trouble myself figuring out why we keep finding mutations so much in Ashkenazi Jews,” said Mark Skolnik, chief scientific officer at Myriad Genetics, a Salt Lake City, Utah, laboratory.

“Why should this happen in Ashkenazim and not other populations? The answer is that we don’t understand,” he said.

“The mystery is not that there’s a specific mutation in a specific population. That’s to be expected. The mystery is that they’re so frequent” among Ashkenazi Jews, he added.

The breast cancer discoveries illuminates growing concerns about the privacy of genetic test results and the way that information might be used by medical insurance companies and employers to discriminate against those whose genes deem them predisposed toward serious disease.

The colon cancer discovery has prompted the same concerns, but with a twist.

Even if a woman is tested and found to have the breast cancer mutations, there is little she can do.

She can change her diet and exercise habits, which can somewhat reduce her chances of being stricken with cancer, but short of having a prophylactic mastectomy — amputating healthy breasts — that is all.

In contrast, colon cancer can be detected very early and, in many cases, it can be prevented with periodic colonoscopies.

The uncomfortable and unloved procedure involves inserting a long, viewing device up the rectum into the large intestine to search for and remove pre- cancerous growths called polyps.

The test is generally recommended for people over 50, and could become a way for people with the genetic predisposition to monitor their colons starting at even an earlier age.

But Brensinger of Johns Hopkins said that only people with a parent, child or sibling with the disease are encouraged to have colonoscopies prior to age 50.

Because the ramifications of the discovery have not yet been explored, it is not clear yet whether health professionals will encourage genetic testing for all Ashkenazi Jews.

Only Johns Hopkins currently offers the test for the genetic mutation particular to Ashkenazi Jews, but more of the country’s several dozen genetic testing labs are expected to begin doing it in the next month or two.

Hopkins began offering the test on Tuesday, but Brensinger said she wasn’t sure how many people have signed up to take it.

The test, at $200, is cheap compared to the breast cancer gene test, which costs $2,400. Only a single genetic base must be examined for the colon cancer test in contrast to 17,500 genetic bases for the breast cancer mutation, Skolnik said.

Over 30 health insurance companies pay for the breast cancer test, he said, and more are signing up all the time.

Some are voicing concerns over potential discrimination from medical insurers and employers in connection with the new discovery, especially among those who have experienced such discrimination in relation to the breast cancer gene.

Such discrimination prompted congressional action to prevent health insurance discrimination against certain people found to have genetic predisposition to serious diseases.

Congress is slated to consider a new bill that would extend that legislation. Advocates hope that this new finding will help move the current bill forward.

But for Marcie Natan, of Lancaster, Pa., the fear of testing is real. She has breast cancer, as does her sister. Their mother died of colon cancer.

When Marcie’s daughter and niece, who are in their mid-20s, sought genetic testing for breast cancer a couple of years ago, genetic researchers discouraged them.

“They told us that privacy wasn’t guaranteed down the road,” said Natan, because insurance companies have access to all medical records.

“Every time you turn around these girls are changing jobs and health insurance companies, and we just don’t want to risk” their facing discrimination, she said.

For the same reasons, Natan’s family is not now considering being tested for the colon cancer mutation, even though her mother died from that disease.

Founding Funders

The digitization of the JTA Archive would not have been possible without the generous support of the following donors:
  • The Gottesman Fund
  • Righteous Persons Foundation
  • Charles H. Revson Foundation
  • Elisa Spungen Bildner and Robert Bildner, in honor of Norma Spungen
  • George S. Blumenthal
  • Grace and Scott Offen Charitable Fund