Pro-palestinian Hotbed in Montreal Erupts, Canceling Netanyahu Speech
Menu JTA Search

Pro-palestinian Hotbed in Montreal Erupts, Canceling Netanyahu Speech

Download PDF for this date

Concordia University long has been a center of Palestinian nationalism, but the Montreal school’s pro-Arab fervor reached new heights this week.

Former Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu canceled a speech at Concordia on Monday after pro-Palestinian demonstrators wreaked havoc in the building.

Protesters threw chairs and other objects at police, who responded with tear gas.

By the time the smoke had cleared, the university’s main lobby was littered with broken glass and chairs.

After the speech was canceled, pro-Israel activists, whom police had asked to remain quietly inside the auditorium, spoke out.

“This is our school. This is not Gaza, this is not Bir Zeit University,” shouted Yoni Petel, the president of Montreal Hillel. “If tomorrow there is another riot, we will not let them take it away from us. We will stand here proudly once again.”

Thomas Hecht, the Quebec chairman of the Canada-Israel Committee, had more disturbing news.

Hecht was spit on and kicked while accompanying the kipah-wearing Rabbi Mordecai Zeitz through the growing mob. Later, it was learned that many others were also attacked.

The pro-Palestinian demonstrators later argued with Netanyahu supporters.

“To prevent an open debate, a lecture in a university, by a representative of a democratic society, of course that is wrong,” an angry Netanyahu later said at a news conference.

The incident was more violent than one in November 2000, when pro-Palestinian demonstrators prevented Netanyahu from speaking at the University of California at Berkeley.

Concordia’s rector, Frederick Lowy, said the university administration had been worried about the speech when it agreed to host Netanyahu.

“Sure, it was a concern, with lots of potential for trouble at our multi-cultural campus,” he told JTA. “Because of their numbers, those who are pro-Palestinian and pro-Israel dominate the scene here. It is frustrating for us, in that the activities on our campus are distracted by these events.”

Because of the university’s emphasis on freedom of speech, it was decided after consultation with security officials that the Hillel request would be accepted.

Academic Norman Finkelstein, a critic of Holocaust groups and of Israel, is slated to speak at Corcordia next week, Lowy said.

B’nai Brith Canada denounced the pro-Palestinian protests.

“The leadership of the Palestinian cause in Canada has failed in its responsibility to ensure that their supporters act with restraint and respect the rights of others,” the group’s executive vice president, Frank Diamant, said in a statement. “Using violence and intimidation to silence other points of view may be the way things are done in certain Middle Eastern dictatorships, but in Canada we must uphold the democratic principles that allowed every community the right to speak out within the limits of the law.”

Approximately 250 people staged a more peaceful protest Monday night outside Netanyahu’s speaking engagement in Winnipeg, where he called for democracy in the Arab world.

On Tuesday he was slated to meet with Canadian Prime Minister Jean Chretien and speak in Toronto.

Netanyahu had been scheduled to speak inside Concordia’s downtown campus building at noon Monday. But the vocal Palestinian lobby at Concordia had made it clear from the outset that its goal was to prevent the speech.

Demonstrators, most of whom appeared to be of Arab origin, began congregating by 9:30 a.m. An hour later, the crowd had grown to about 350, but the atmosphere appeared calm.

Organizers chanted slogans like “End the occupation now,” “One, two three, four, occupation no more,” “Free, free Palestine” and “Justice for Palestine.”

Palestinian flags, and others with images of Argentine revolutionary Che Guevara, flew freely. A group of young men were overheard discussing who was the “baddest” Israeli prime minister — Ehud Barak, Netanyahu or Ariel Sharon.

Nearby, fliers glued to building walls declared, “Benjamin Netanyahu is coming to Montreal. Let’s make it clear he’s not welcome.” Others included a”warrant” for Netanyahu’s arrest as a war criminal.

By 11 a.m., people with one of the 600 tickets made available to the public were permitted inside, passing through tight security.

Half the hall was filled when Lowy announced that a demonstration outside was out of control, and people were admitted more slowly.

Not long afterward, at approximately 1:15 p.m., Lowy took the podium once more. Netanyahu’s personal security team had decided not to allow him to enter the fray outside the building, he said, where police were now using tear gas to disperse the ugly crowd.

Those inside the auditorium were asked to remain until it was safe for them to leave.

Subsequent pro-Israel chanting and singing drew a rebuke from a university official, who warned this could inflame those outside.

“We won’t be ashamed of who we are,” one student yelled, to unanimous applause.

Speaker after speaker denounced the nastiness outside.

“Don’t go down into the gutter, to do the kinds of things meant to intimidate, like the people outside are doing,” Zeitz advised.

Speaking to the media later, backed by Montreal Jewish leaders, Netanyahu denounced the protesters.

“What these people showed you today is that they’re absolutely intolerant, absolutely extreme, in their totalitarian mentality,” he said. “This is exactly totalitarianism versus freedom, which is at the heart of the battle being waged on the world stage.”

He also accused the demonstrators of supporting Iraqi President Saddam Hussein, Palestinian Authority President Yasser Arafat and Al-Qaida terrorist mastermind Osama bin Laden.

Founding Funders

The digitization of the JTA Archive would not have been possible without the generous support of the following donors:
  • The Gottesman Fund
  • Righteous Persons Foundation
  • Charles H. Revson Foundation
  • Elisa Spungen Bildner and Robert Bildner, in honor of Norma Spungen
  • George S. Blumenthal
  • Grace and Scott Offen Charitable Fund